I think that's what I'm going to call the group, for now--at least until someone suggests something better. (I know a concern is a business, but it's a grand pun)
In any case, the meeting with Kendra went quite well. We settled on a very practical idea that would meet some of my needs and, hopefully help a bunch of interested parties.
One of the best things about UB's MFA is that there really is an opportunity to make it your own--a lot is possible. So, for those interested in teaching, there are some opportunities becoming available, more all the time I'd imagine. But my primary goal was to build a group around the CV, cover letter and statement of teaching philosophy. Sometime this weekend I'm getting an email together that's, essentially, a call for like-minded folks (this goes for people in the program, those about to finish or new, and alumni--we are here to help! All interested parties welcome). I don't have a sense of who's interested and who's not, so let me lay some of the ideas out...
1) We need to meet--see who we are, what we think we need to achieve, put heads together.
2) The ultimate goal is to draft the necessary documents for applying for tenure-track jobs, but I think we should begin with the cover letter. One of the ideas Kendra helped me keep in focus is that UB is a unique program, and that needs to be reflected in the letter. So we need to not just build a letter suited to ourselves as individuals, but letters that maximize the kinds of things that might set us apart as graduates of this particular program. For example: most of us would be not only capable of overseeing a student literary magazine, but designing and producing it (with student help and input, of course) as well. These kinds of skills could add a whole new dimension to a candidate that employers may not even know they need/want (until we tell them in our fabulous letters).
3) One of my goals is to meet with some UB career counselors about this--hopefully, I can swing this prior to our meeting as a group...
4) Another goal, of course, is to develop a CV in the same fashion (we'll worry about particulars later) but Kendra had a nice idea of developing a standard for students that would be like what designers put together: a CD with digital photographs or copies of design work--a portfolio on disc. In addition to the traditional CV, that could be a great asset. I plan to talk to some of the design professors about what these are like.
I'm excited. Any ideas?--the door remains open to comments.
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Monday, February 25, 2008
Today
I probably should have thought of this earlier, but I have a meeting with Kendra today and I want to share with her some of the ideas I've expressed here in the blog. If any one of the thousands who read this want to express an interest or idea about this stuff (especially about the tenure-track-group-that-needs-a-better-name-
and-despite-claiming-to-be-a-writer-I-seem-
to-be-unable-to-conjure-up-anything)--let me know.
and-despite-claiming-to-be-a-writer-I-seem-
to-be-unable-to-conjure-up-anything)--let me know.
Sunday, February 24, 2008
Not to change the subject,
but can we get rid of this term "graphic novel"? I find it a bit pretentious as it seems to be the only way some people can justify reading comics.
"Comics" sounds, I think, to some, like something that must be funny (like the "funny papers") but even the funny papers weren't always funny--adventure and educational strips have always been part of what we consider comics (think Steve Canyon or Mark Trail). Graphic novel hews a bit too closely to "novel" and, despite what the boosters of this term may believe, comics are not novels with illustrations. A decent comic is one that uses words and images to convey a message not unlike the way a film does (another somewhat pretentious term--"cinema" is another and "motion picture" the worst).
But how are we to separate serious art from crappy superhero stuff, you may ask? By reading it! Segregating the medium in this way smacks of snobbery (in the same way people say "genre fiction"--they used to say the same thing about American writers). I worry that we are dividing comics into black and white memoir (art) and colorful people with capes (trash).
The earliest use of "graphic novel" that I recall was when Will Eisner started publishing books in the late seventies (A Contract with God, for example) and it became a way to market it to those interested in art. A few years later, DC comics used it to describe Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns--a book starring Batman. For a long time after that it seemed to me the term was either applied by pretentious art kids who read anything autobiographical and black and white (like Yummy Fur) or pretentious comic store owners who were looking for ways to milk more money from teenagers who liked Batman--but this one is darker, more violent, and hardcover!
It seems the art kids won that battle, but every now and then, I read a review in a mainstream publication or hear a traditional comics artist refer to his or her work as being a graphic novel. Poppycock--it's comics.
"Poppycock?" Alright, I'm officially too old to have an opinion on this. Converse among yourselves...
"Comics" sounds, I think, to some, like something that must be funny (like the "funny papers") but even the funny papers weren't always funny--adventure and educational strips have always been part of what we consider comics (think Steve Canyon or Mark Trail). Graphic novel hews a bit too closely to "novel" and, despite what the boosters of this term may believe, comics are not novels with illustrations. A decent comic is one that uses words and images to convey a message not unlike the way a film does (another somewhat pretentious term--"cinema" is another and "motion picture" the worst).
But how are we to separate serious art from crappy superhero stuff, you may ask? By reading it! Segregating the medium in this way smacks of snobbery (in the same way people say "genre fiction"--they used to say the same thing about American writers). I worry that we are dividing comics into black and white memoir (art) and colorful people with capes (trash).
The earliest use of "graphic novel" that I recall was when Will Eisner started publishing books in the late seventies (A Contract with God, for example) and it became a way to market it to those interested in art. A few years later, DC comics used it to describe Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns--a book starring Batman. For a long time after that it seemed to me the term was either applied by pretentious art kids who read anything autobiographical and black and white (like Yummy Fur) or pretentious comic store owners who were looking for ways to milk more money from teenagers who liked Batman--but this one is darker, more violent, and hardcover!
It seems the art kids won that battle, but every now and then, I read a review in a mainstream publication or hear a traditional comics artist refer to his or her work as being a graphic novel. Poppycock--it's comics.
"Poppycock?" Alright, I'm officially too old to have an opinion on this. Converse among yourselves...
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
The Death of Print
is of course, greatly exaggerated. I had a brief conversation with a text book representative this morning, and the direction in which the text book companies seem to be moving is fairly exciting.
I like the idea of content moving online--making a composition book available electronically, for example--but I think we may have to have a conversation about some potential issues with access. Text books are too expensive, and making them available electronically should cut into that--I mean, editing and reproducing material on the web is not free, but the material and shipping costs are relatively negligible. So why do I get the feeling prices for online materials, in ten to fifteen years, won't reflect this change? This is why I think educators (and future educators) need to stay on top of some of these developments. Adoption choices are a big part of what we do, and this is where we can exercise some control. Being concerned about student access, I think, is part of our responsibility if we're at all concerned with some of the social justice aspects of being teachers.
Not everyone has a laptop. Nor do all students even have home access to computers or the internet. While we try as much as possible to minimize any problems with this, it is somewhat more difficult for some students, especially if they have jobs or families, to fit computer lab time into their schedules. Not all schools have 24-hour labs. In fact, I wonder if that may becoming a thing of the past. When I was an undergrad, it seemed like labs were open all the time, but word processing was important and most students didn't have their own computers--the internet was just a baby and not at all fast. The idea that a student could research, compose and print a paper at any time of day from his/her dorm, was, basically, a fantasy. At many schools today, I'd imagine it's the norm.
So while it will be (it's technically feasible now) possible to move away from print text books, how much of them will end up getting printed out in computer labs? Students without access will have a tougher time accessing the material. And simply offering financial aid or scholarships for text books will not really solve this problem. So are we moving toward programs that will provide students with laptops? I'd like to hope that if text book companies are really serious about moving away from print, that they consider subsidizing some programs that can provide students with laptops (reconditioned, whatever--students don't need state of the art machines to access the web wirelessly and word process documents). Even if they are "loaners" or something that can get a student through college, I think this is going to be necessary sooner than we think.
I like the idea of content moving online--making a composition book available electronically, for example--but I think we may have to have a conversation about some potential issues with access. Text books are too expensive, and making them available electronically should cut into that--I mean, editing and reproducing material on the web is not free, but the material and shipping costs are relatively negligible. So why do I get the feeling prices for online materials, in ten to fifteen years, won't reflect this change? This is why I think educators (and future educators) need to stay on top of some of these developments. Adoption choices are a big part of what we do, and this is where we can exercise some control. Being concerned about student access, I think, is part of our responsibility if we're at all concerned with some of the social justice aspects of being teachers.
Not everyone has a laptop. Nor do all students even have home access to computers or the internet. While we try as much as possible to minimize any problems with this, it is somewhat more difficult for some students, especially if they have jobs or families, to fit computer lab time into their schedules. Not all schools have 24-hour labs. In fact, I wonder if that may becoming a thing of the past. When I was an undergrad, it seemed like labs were open all the time, but word processing was important and most students didn't have their own computers--the internet was just a baby and not at all fast. The idea that a student could research, compose and print a paper at any time of day from his/her dorm, was, basically, a fantasy. At many schools today, I'd imagine it's the norm.
So while it will be (it's technically feasible now) possible to move away from print text books, how much of them will end up getting printed out in computer labs? Students without access will have a tougher time accessing the material. And simply offering financial aid or scholarships for text books will not really solve this problem. So are we moving toward programs that will provide students with laptops? I'd like to hope that if text book companies are really serious about moving away from print, that they consider subsidizing some programs that can provide students with laptops (reconditioned, whatever--students don't need state of the art machines to access the web wirelessly and word process documents). Even if they are "loaners" or something that can get a student through college, I think this is going to be necessary sooner than we think.
Sunday, February 17, 2008
Another terminal degree question
If an MFA is a terminal degree, should another master's be strongly advised for those seeking the MFA? I'm not exactly sure where my thinking is going here, but many, not all, PhD programs require a master's and/or have candidates pursue one (that's why so many people receive an MA from their PhD institutions). As a result, those with a PhD are qualified in the less specialized field as well--at least in terms of teaching at the 100 or 200 levels. Getting a PhD means that a person is ultra-specialized--having more than an area of interest or concentration, this person is now an expert in a narrow field of study. This would seem to be true of an MFA graduate--it is true one specializes in broad areas like poetry or fiction, but in some sense, one becomes a specialist in his/her own work. There is constant advice about the kinds of writers a candidate should read in terms of the work he/she is trying to complete for the program (this is all appropriate, I think) but it can leave a person with a BA in, say, philosophy (like myself) and an MFA with a pretty spotty literature background--not to mention a sparse background in collegiate writing (composition, technical, etc.) especially from the point of view of an employer.
There are too many MFA programs creating too many graduates who want jobs teaching, of which there aren't many. Obviously, many of us will have to "settle" for teaching composition or literature. The question is are we qualified to teach these subjects, or, rather, are we perceived to be qualified? That's the trick. Applying for a job where one may be asked to teach four or five sections of composition a semester may not be very likely when the MFA thesis is a chapbook and there's little evidence of academic research or writing throughout the program. Again, I'm not saying this matters (the best preparation for teaching comp is teaching comp) but might it matter to prospective employers? I used to think the MFA would put me slightly ahead of those with mere MAs, but now I'm not so sure. I have an MA already, but does the MFA really matter if I can't get a book (or two!) published (a probable requirement to teach creative writing)? Was I better off going into a PhD program (although they have their own "producing more than we can hire" issues)?
From a future job standpoint--I don't know. It's a bit academic at this point (I'm fairly close to being finished) but it may be something to consider as we think about the particular program at UB, as well as other programs around the country.
Finally, I will say this: in terms of fiction writing, this degree has been the best thing I've ever done. I think my work is miles above what it had been. In terms of being an artist, irrespective of jobs or publication, I would do it again and again--I'm just wondering about how to make the best of the piece of parchment I'll receive and those who will come behind me.
There are too many MFA programs creating too many graduates who want jobs teaching, of which there aren't many. Obviously, many of us will have to "settle" for teaching composition or literature. The question is are we qualified to teach these subjects, or, rather, are we perceived to be qualified? That's the trick. Applying for a job where one may be asked to teach four or five sections of composition a semester may not be very likely when the MFA thesis is a chapbook and there's little evidence of academic research or writing throughout the program. Again, I'm not saying this matters (the best preparation for teaching comp is teaching comp) but might it matter to prospective employers? I used to think the MFA would put me slightly ahead of those with mere MAs, but now I'm not so sure. I have an MA already, but does the MFA really matter if I can't get a book (or two!) published (a probable requirement to teach creative writing)? Was I better off going into a PhD program (although they have their own "producing more than we can hire" issues)?
From a future job standpoint--I don't know. It's a bit academic at this point (I'm fairly close to being finished) but it may be something to consider as we think about the particular program at UB, as well as other programs around the country.
Finally, I will say this: in terms of fiction writing, this degree has been the best thing I've ever done. I think my work is miles above what it had been. In terms of being an artist, irrespective of jobs or publication, I would do it again and again--I'm just wondering about how to make the best of the piece of parchment I'll receive and those who will come behind me.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Everyone
go over to Rose's blog and wish her well. Go ahead. I'll wait.
Okay, so I consider myself to be pretty lucky, having good health insurance and all, but it's pretty crazy to hear this story of the woe of the insured. Antibiotics, of course, are overprescribed and I think Rose is right to be concerned about being on lots of different antibiotics in a month's span, especially when it sounds like she just wants enough relief to sleep (not some magical cure that probably doesn't exist!). Paying through the nose to wait in a crowded and uncomfortable facility to see someone who isn't a doctor and is probably overworked is supposed to be why we don't want nationalized medicine. Most people who are lucky enough to have insurance have that now! The "system" we have now is awful and broken!
Whew--sorry about that. I find the rest of Rose's blog to be a nice antidote to mine (which feels like a boring notebook sometimes). I like the snips of remembered dialogue especially.
Rose--I tend to mistrust most drugs and medicines (made it tough to make friends in college) but when you're that sick, you've earned the right to a little codine....
Okay, so I consider myself to be pretty lucky, having good health insurance and all, but it's pretty crazy to hear this story of the woe of the insured. Antibiotics, of course, are overprescribed and I think Rose is right to be concerned about being on lots of different antibiotics in a month's span, especially when it sounds like she just wants enough relief to sleep (not some magical cure that probably doesn't exist!). Paying through the nose to wait in a crowded and uncomfortable facility to see someone who isn't a doctor and is probably overworked is supposed to be why we don't want nationalized medicine. Most people who are lucky enough to have insurance have that now! The "system" we have now is awful and broken!
Whew--sorry about that. I find the rest of Rose's blog to be a nice antidote to mine (which feels like a boring notebook sometimes). I like the snips of remembered dialogue especially.
Rose--I tend to mistrust most drugs and medicines (made it tough to make friends in college) but when you're that sick, you've earned the right to a little codine....
Yet another post about tenure track
The semester seemed to slam into full tilt pretty quickly--with the weather problems and a nasty couple of nights with a head cold (I'm now in the cool, after glow of illness where my voice sounds like the Master Control Program from Tron) I find myself in the crush of work usually reserved for the weeks just prior to exams.
One of the things I'm trying to do is serve on a search committee to get an idea of what I may be in for. Obviously, I can't blog much about the experience (esp. while in the midst of it) but I hope to be able to bring some better insights to the fledgling group that exists in my brain (we are happy there, we have peace, we are one with Landru).
In other news, I did manage to get my hands on some materials promised at AWP and they're pretty eye-opening--do more readings folks. I also spoke to a few other MFAers about the group and there seems to be some interest out there.
One of the things I'm trying to do is serve on a search committee to get an idea of what I may be in for. Obviously, I can't blog much about the experience (esp. while in the midst of it) but I hope to be able to bring some better insights to the fledgling group that exists in my brain (we are happy there, we have peace, we are one with Landru).
In other news, I did manage to get my hands on some materials promised at AWP and they're pretty eye-opening--do more readings folks. I also spoke to a few other MFAers about the group and there seems to be some interest out there.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)